In-depth research - Who is stronger?
Author：Warpath BJWG
2024-04-01 18:28:16
In this in-depth research, we will compare the 4th generation Exclusive Lounge Officer Steel Phoenix, with the 3rd generation Exclusive Lounge Officer: Lord of Order, Professor Pain.
(The difference between the Dmg buff of the Attacker and the Dmg Resist of the Defender will be calculated. If it is greater than 0, the Dmg increased, otherwise it will reduce the damage, with a maximum difference of 50%.)
Let us first look at the skill comparison：
The basic Dmg coefficients of tactical skills are the same. Steel Phoenix’s tactical skill also increases Dmg by 15%, and it can last for 8s, which is equivalent to an additional 15% Dmg once the skill Dmg is released. In comparison, Professor Pain's additional shield and Lord of Order's conditional additional low Dmg coefficient appear to be a level lower.
Let us first look at the skill comparison：
| Tactical Skill | critical | |
| Steel Phoenix | Vengeful Blaze Lvl 1 Prep Time: 8s Deals Dmg to an enemy (Dmg Coefficient 1800). lf this Officer is in a Tank or Helicopter Troop, this skill also increases the Troop's Dmg by 15% for 8s. |
This Officer's Troop has a 15% chance to land a Critical Strike with its normal attacks, dealing 150% Dmg. Additionally, its critical Dmg for normal attacks is increased by an extra 50%. |
| Professor Pain | Battle Furor Lvl 1 Prep Time: 8s Deals Dmg to an enemy (Dmg Coefficient 1800). If this Officer is in a Tank or Helicopter Troop, it will also gain a shield worth 25% of the Dmg dealt for 4s. |
If this Officer is in a Tank or Helicopter Troop, all Officers in their Troop have a 30% chance to land a Critical Strike when using a skill. lf an Officer lands a Critical Strike with a skill, it deals 150% Dmg |
| Lord of Order | Motivator Lvl 1 Prep Time: 8s Deals Dmg to an enemy (Dmg Coefficient 1800). lf this Officer is in a Tank or Helicopter Troop and the Troop's HP is over 70%, this skill deals extra Dmg (Dmg Coefficient 450) |
The basic Dmg coefficients of tactical skills are the same. Steel Phoenix’s tactical skill also increases Dmg by 15%, and it can last for 8s, which is equivalent to an additional 15% Dmg once the skill Dmg is released. In comparison, Professor Pain's additional shield and Lord of Order's conditional additional low Dmg coefficient appear to be a level lower.
Steel Phoenix's normal attack has a chance to land a critical strike, and the critical strike Dmg can be increased to 200%. This is more likely to trigger than Professor Pain's skill critical strike. Although the chance of triggering is different, the gap between normal and skill attack is too big.
Steel Phoenix has both Dmg buff and Dmg Resist buff, which makes it more advantageous than Professor Pain, which only has one buff, or even Lord of Order.
Steel Phoenix VS Professor Pain
Steel Phoenix Dmg buff 15%
Professor Pain Dmg buff 20%-10%=10%
Steel Phoenix VS Lord of Order
Steel Phoenix Dmg buff 15%+10%=25%
Lord of Order Dmg buff 25%-10%=15%
Steel Phoenix 's Dmg buff is better than that of the other two officers.
Professor Pain and Lord of Order have tactical skills that reduce damage or increase damage. Steel Phoenix increases damage with normal attacks, which stacks with its normal attack critical strike ability, giving a better effect.
The Load Time reduction is unique to Steel Phoenix and is very suitable for normal attacks. Steel Phoenix will restore HP every 4s, which is much better than Lord of Order’s 20% chance of recovery. Compared with the other two officers, the only disadvantage of Steel Phoenix is that there is no HP buff.
| Dmg Increase | Dmg Resist | |
| Steel Phoenix | This Officer's Troop deals 15% extra normal attack Dmg, Increases the Dmg of this Officer's Tank and Helicopter Troops by 15% |
Increases the Dmg Resist of this Officer's Tank and Helicopter Troops by 10% |
| Professor Pain | Increases the Dmg of this Officer's Troop by 20%. When attacking an enemy with a shield, increases their Troop's Dmg by an extra 20%. | Reduces the Skill Dmg this Officer's Tanks and Helicopters take by 30%. |
| Lord of Order | While in combat, increases the Dmg of this Officer's Tanks and Helicopters by 25%. Has no effect outside of combat. Increases the Firepower of this Officer's Tanks and Helicopters by 20% Increases the Skill Dmg of all Officers in this Officer's Troop by 30%. |
While in combat, reduces their DmgResist by 10%. Has no effect outside of combat. |
Steel Phoenix has both Dmg buff and Dmg Resist buff, which makes it more advantageous than Professor Pain, which only has one buff, or even Lord of Order.
Steel Phoenix VS Professor Pain
Steel Phoenix Dmg buff 15%
Professor Pain Dmg buff 20%-10%=10%
Steel Phoenix VS Lord of Order
Steel Phoenix Dmg buff 15%+10%=25%
Lord of Order Dmg buff 25%-10%=15%
Steel Phoenix 's Dmg buff is better than that of the other two officers.
Professor Pain and Lord of Order have tactical skills that reduce damage or increase damage. Steel Phoenix increases damage with normal attacks, which stacks with its normal attack critical strike ability, giving a better effect.
| Reduce Load Time | recover | |
| Steel Phoenix | This Officer's Load Time is reduced by 10%. | While this Officer's Tank or Helicopter Troop is attacking its targets in the field, it recovers HP every 4s equal to 10% of the Dmg dealt within 4s. The excess HP recovered is converted to Shield HP for the Troop, which lasts for 4s. (The Shield HP cannot exceed 10% of the Troop's max HP.) |
| Professor Pain | If this Officer is in a Tank or Helicopter Troop, it gains a 30% bonus to HP and recovers 1% HP per second while in the field and not in combat. | |
| Lord of Order | Whenever this Officer's Troop is attacked, it has a 20% chance to recover HP (Healing Coefficient 250) Can trigger once every 4s. Increases the HP of this Officer's Tanks and Helicopters by 20%. |
The Load Time reduction is unique to Steel Phoenix and is very suitable for normal attacks. Steel Phoenix will restore HP every 4s, which is much better than Lord of Order’s 20% chance of recovery. Compared with the other two officers, the only disadvantage of Steel Phoenix is that there is no HP buff.
What kind of officer we pair depends on what unit we mainly use it to fight against. If it is an output unit, it generally does not stack too much Dmg Resist, so as long as the Dmg buff stack to a certain level, we don’t need to add more Dmg buff, because the maximum Dmg buff is only 50%. If we need to fight against a tank unit, the opponent will usually stack Dmg Resist buff. At this time, the more Dmg buff, the better.
We used a helicopter under the same conditions to test with Steel Phoenix and Professor Pain Standing shooting in actual combat. The recovery ability of Steel Phoenix is significantly greater than that of Professor Pain. Professor Pain has a 20% chance to recover when attacked, while Steel Phoenix recovers at a fixed rate every 4s. This leads to the fact that in the first few rounds of attacks, Professor Pain can compete with Steel Phoenix. But in the third round of attacking, Steel Phoenix 's recovery began to take effect, and it began to overtake Professor Pain in combat power. At the same time, when Professor Pain's unit's HP is lower than 70%, Professor Pain's tactical skill to deal additional Dmg disappears.
Yellow represents who starts attacking first
We used a helicopter under the same conditions to test with Steel Phoenix and Lord of Order Standing shooting in actual combat. Steel Phoenix 's advantage in normal attacks widens the gap between the two sides. Although Steel Phoenix 's critical strike rate is only 15%, there is a chance of a critical strike with every normal attack. The Lord of Order's tactical skills have a 30% chance of a critical strike, but it each time takes 8s to release. Steel Phoenix has a higher chance to land a critical strike.
To sum up, if Steel Phoenix stands and attacks, it is far better than Professor Pain and Lord of Order. In the test, Steel Phoenix mostly used normal attacks to widen the gap. Using high burst damage units such as helicopter can better play its role.
We used a helicopter under the same conditions to test with Steel Phoenix and Professor Pain Standing shooting in actual combat. The recovery ability of Steel Phoenix is significantly greater than that of Professor Pain. Professor Pain has a 20% chance to recover when attacked, while Steel Phoenix recovers at a fixed rate every 4s. This leads to the fact that in the first few rounds of attacks, Professor Pain can compete with Steel Phoenix. But in the third round of attacking, Steel Phoenix 's recovery began to take effect, and it began to overtake Professor Pain in combat power. At the same time, when Professor Pain's unit's HP is lower than 70%, Professor Pain's tactical skill to deal additional Dmg disappears.
| Helicopters | ||
| Steel Phoenix | Professor Pain | remain |
| win | 7.77Million | |
| win | 17.77Million | |
| win | 14.43Million | |
| win | 11.1Million | |
| win | 15.54Million | |
| Main Battle Tanks | ||
| Steel Phoenix | Professor Pain | remain |
| win | 8.88Million | |
| win | 12.21 | |
| win | 11.1Million | |
| win | 13.32Million | |
| win | 12.21Million | |
We used a helicopter under the same conditions to test with Steel Phoenix and Lord of Order Standing shooting in actual combat. Steel Phoenix 's advantage in normal attacks widens the gap between the two sides. Although Steel Phoenix 's critical strike rate is only 15%, there is a chance of a critical strike with every normal attack. The Lord of Order's tactical skills have a 30% chance of a critical strike, but it each time takes 8s to release. Steel Phoenix has a higher chance to land a critical strike.
| Helicopters | ||
| Steel Phoenix | Lord of Order | remain |
| win | 13.32Million | |
| win | 5.55Million | |
| win | 11.1Million | |
| win | 12.21Million | |
| win | 11.1Million | |
| Main Battle Tanks | ||
| Steel Phoenix | Lord of Order | remain |
| win | 13.32Million | |
| win | 11.1Million | |
| win | 88.8Million | |
| win | 14.43Million | |
| win | 13.32Million | |
To sum up, if Steel Phoenix stands and attacks, it is far better than Professor Pain and Lord of Order. In the test, Steel Phoenix mostly used normal attacks to widen the gap. Using high burst damage units such as helicopter can better play its role.